Modern or Character-Filled Home? The Pros and Cons of Both - Home & Texture
Home Modern or Character

Is Your Dream Home Modern or One With Character? Here Are the Pros and Cons of Both

December 8, 2023 at 8:26 AM PST

In the exciting journey of choosing your dream home, you might be confronted with a dilemma—should you go for a sleek and contemporary modern home or a charming, character-filled abode? Both styles have their unique appeal, and making the right choice is essential to make sure your home aligns perfectly with your lifestyle and preferences. Explore the pros and cons of both to help you make a well-thought-out decision.

Charming furniture
Photo Credit: Charlotte May

What makes a modern home vs. a home with character?

A modern home is defined by its sleek and minimalist design, emphasizing clean lines, open spaces, and a focus on functionality. It seamlessly integrates the latest technology and energy-efficient features, often resulting in aesthetically pleasing living spaces that prioritize contemporary aesthetics and convenience.

In contrast, a character-filled home is a timeless classic that typically has warmth and unique charm—a certain je ne sais quoi. It can feature original architectural details, such as hardwood floors, crown molding, ornate fireplaces, and stained glass windows. These homes carry a rich history, connecting occupants to the past and offering ample opportunities for personalization and customization while retaining a timeless appeal.

What To Consider When Purchasing Either Type of Home

First, consider your budget and financial readiness. Determine how much you can comfortably afford for both the down payment and ongoing mortgage payments. A brand new modern home with all the tech-forward bells and whistles might not be as practical as an older home with character and tons of potential to customize down the road.

Secondly, location plays a pivotal role in your decision. Think about your lifestyle preferences and needs. Do you want to be in a bustling urban area, a quiet suburban neighborhood, or perhaps a rural setting? This can affect whether you’ll end up with a modern home or a character-filled one.

Modern dining room
Photo Credit: Houzlook

Pros of Modern Homes

  • Sleek Aesthetics: Modern homes offer a clean and contemporary look that is visually stunning.
  • Technological Advancements: They tend to come equipped with the latest technology, making daily life more convenient.
  • Energy Efficiency: Modern homes are designed with sustainability in mind, potentially leading to significant savings on utility bills.
  • Low Maintenance: Their minimalist design often translates to lower maintenance requirements.

Cons of Modern Homes

  • Can Feel Cookie-Cutter: Some may find modern homes a bit sterile or devoid of personality, or look like every other home you see on Pinterest.
  • Higher Cost: While the maintenance is overall low, the sleek features and technology can come at a premium price.
  • Limited Customization: Modern homes may not allow for the same level of personalization as character-filled homes.
Character dining room
Photo Credit: Charlotte May

Pros of Character-filled Homes

  • Charming Aesthetics: Character-filled homes naturally feel cozy, and things like slight creaks in floorboards and brick walls add a sense of unique style.
  • Rich History: They carry a sense of history and heritage that connects you to the past.
  • Customization: You can personalize character-filled homes to reflect your style and preferences.
  • Timelessness: The classic design elements promise that these homes remain visually appealing, not going after the latest trends.

Cons of Character-filled Homes

  • Expensive Maintenance: These often older homes might have stuff that doesn’t work quite like it used to. They may require more maintenance and occasional repairs, which can get costly to replace.
  • Limited Modern Amenities: Older homes may lack modern conveniences, like central air or insulation.
  • Energy Inefficiency: They may not be as energy-efficient as modern homes.



Find us on social for more home inspiration where culture, personal style, and sophisticated shopping intersect to help you create a home where you love to live.